- It’s Showtime was highly criticized for TNT Ultimate Resbak’s result.
- K Brosas defended her fellow hurados from bashers.
Many netizens are still in disbelief with the results of It’s Showtime’s Tawag ng Tanghalan Ultimate Resbak.
Furious netizens took to social media platforms Twitter and Facebook to share their sentiments regarding the results of Mariane Osabel and Mariko Ledesma’s head-to-head showdown.
The netizens who were mostly supporters of Marianne slammed the show and its hurados for their alleged biased and unfair judging.
Unfair score
On Tuesday, September 11, Mariane Osabel of Mindanao and Mariko Ledesma went on a head-to head battle in Tawag Ng Tanghalan’s Ultimate Resbak. Marianne was the owner of the seat of power that time while Mariko was the challenger.
After their performance, the hurados chose Mariko as the winner making her the new owner of the seat of power leaving Mariane out of the competition.
Mariko got a total average score of 83.74%, 33.74% of which came from public votes and 50% from hurados’ votes, while Mariane got a total score of 66.5%, 50% from public votes and 16.5% from the hurados.
Furious Netizens
That decision didn’t sit well with the netizens, making the hashtags ‘#JusticeforMariane’ and ‘#TNTUltimateResbak’ trending topics on Twitter Philippines.
Most of the netizens slammed the show and the judges saying the result is very incredible and unbelievable. Many of them bashed the hurados for being ‘biased,’ saying the singing competition is now relegated to a cooking show.
Here are some of their tweets.
https://twitter.com/curated_tweets/status/1171689617621258240?s=19
https://twitter.com/ronaele22/status/1171961705531752450?s=19
https://twitter.com/_caladrius_/status/1171692224683241472?s=19
Gabi na but Mariane is still trending tho. Seems everybody can’t get over with the confusing score of hurados lmao. She’s definitely robbed! #TNTUltimateResbak
— 🦋 (@maria_elaineeee) September 11, 2019
https://twitter.com/micogzz/status/1171958617672568832?s=19
https://twitter.com/lowedziih/status/1171714136004149249?s=19
All of the judges’ decisions are so fucking disappointing today. From Mr. Q&A to Tawag ng Tanghalan. Congrats to Mariko but 16.50% for Mariane’s performance? Insane. #TNTULtimateResbak
— tom nook (@Camgrierbae) September 11, 2019
https://twitter.com/Kidlet_06/status/1171763282304282624?s=19
https://twitter.com/natsmartina/status/1172028563219865600?s=19
This is no longer a question of why Mariko won over Mariane. Question now is, “Did the hurados HONESTLY think that Mariane deserves an all-time low score of 16.5% given that “close fight” tag yesterday? Like seriously? Paki-explain.#TNTUltimateResbakan #JusticeForMariane
— Love (@lovemarkki) September 12, 2019
K Brosas response
Meanwhile, one of the hurados also took to Twitter to defend the outcome of the show.
Hurado K Brosas shared her views via several tweets saying while she believe with Mariane’s caliber as a singer, Mariko was more deserving that day.
Hindi ko kailangan pakita score ko kahit Di ganon kababa.. At respeto SA kapwa ko hurado Di ko rin tinatanong.. FYI pag May txt votes allowed kami na mag score from 0 to 100.. pero bottom line kahit napaka galing ni mariane talaga.. c mariko ang deserving TODAY.. yes TODAY ✌🏼☺️
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 11, 2019
She also added that whatever the outcome people will have something to say and that winning is not a sure guarantee to stardom.
Daming hanas pag mataas ang TXT VOTES.. chika pa kayo na dapat mas mataas percent ng hurados scores.. PERO hanas pa din pag Natalo dahil mas mataas ang hurados scores kesa txt votes? Eh ganon po talaga.. At tandaan madaming sikat ngayon na Di naman nag grand winner. Peace! ☺️✌🏼
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 11, 2019
This was also what she has to say to the netizen who cursed not only her but other hurados as well.
God bless! 😘 https://t.co/B0PlZbfWZo
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 11, 2019
Kahit ano pa pong mura nyo SA akin, bash na wala na SA issue, At May pagbabanta pa SA buhay ko, kahit ano pang sabihin nyo, wala na tayong lahat magagawa.. ako work na lang uli tom na walang galit SA dibdib.. kaya kung masaya kayo SA ginagawa nyo At galit, gusto nyo yan eh. ✌🏼☺️
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 11, 2019
Lastly, she said that the decision of the hurados are collegial. There were 5 of them who decided, and no matter what netizens say they should just respect the result, the same way that she respect all of their opinions.
Ok last na po to.. uhm.. ako lang po ba ang hurado? No.. nakita nyo po ba ang score ko? No.. pinapakita ba ang individual scores ever since? No.. tama bang sabihan mo ako NG Bobo Kong judge after 3 seasons? No.. o wait opinion mo pala yan kaya ok Lang po. I respect ur opinion ☺️ https://t.co/DPjuuK6Tlo
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 11, 2019
Before I sleep..to all the bashers, happy po? Nakadagdag po ba yan SA ikasasaya NG life at SA mga “pangarap” nyo? Saya siguro NG pambaba bash no? Kahit wala kayong alam. Ako lang talaga super tag at bash nyo kc ako Lang sumagot na MAAYOS naman. Still bash pa more! Eh Di kayo na☺️
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 12, 2019
Daming below the belt na hanas.. sobra.. parang May pinatay akong close nyo.. kaso the question is.. alam nyo ba lahat?? Ako lang nag explain pero Di nyo gets, so pano? Wait na lang po natin statement ng tnt.. wag ako tanungin At mag demand.. May dahilan lahat. Ganon yon. ✌🏼☺️
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 12, 2019
Pati walang kinalaman sa issue nyo, mura at panlalait natanggap ko at namin.. masaya na kayo don? para sabihan Sina miss dulce at sir louie na mahiya naman kayo sa achievements nila pero hanas pa Din? Galing ha! So happy? Ang saya NG feeling ba na may ganyang galit? Eh di ok. ☺️
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 12, 2019
Last na to.. wala kayong alam! Kung ako nga Di alam eh.. wag kayong mag demand saken NG explanation.. Pero kung ano man “issue” wag kayong Bastos sana.. ipaglaban nyo NG maayos kung ano man yon.. wag personal atak na akala mo close tayo, Ingat lang SA hanas kc May batas. Nyt! 😉
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 12, 2019
Ok patulan ko to.. paulit ulit na ako na parang parrot.. hindi ko alam At never pinakita individual scores naming lahat.. alam ko lang score ko.. mag dasal ako?? Dinamay mo Anak ko?? Gano ka kagago?! Nasa contest ba sha na dimunyu ka?? Ingat ka tehh.. Dali hanapin IP address mo! https://t.co/x4blT9VGPA
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 12, 2019
Ok, super last na to .. bash nyo man ako NG bongga kahit wala na sa issue.. ok.. pero May thin line.. lahat kayo knows ko na.. mapa Troll or even naka public At May followers.. Ingat Ingat din po.. wag nyong idamay ang dapat hindi idamay.. kc pakingsyet! Gudluk! Nyt! 😅😡
— carmela brosas (@kbrosas) September 12, 2019
Aware of the disappointment happened during the show, TNT host Vice Ganda informed the netizens that the Hurados will release an official statement after their meeting.
(1) Ok for the TnT fans tweeting me. I talked to the staff and told them that the viewers’ sentiments have to be acknowledged. So i asked if we can hear a word from Sir Louie since sya lng ang judge kahapon na present kanina.
— jose marie viceral (@vicegandako) September 12, 2019
(2) I was told na the Hurados will talk and will come up with a statement after. They’re aware na madaming disappointed. I myself was shocked. And i would love to hear and respect what they would have to say. So lets just wait. Love u guys!
— jose marie viceral (@vicegandako) September 12, 2019
On Friday, acting as the head judge Ogie Alcasid said he hopes that viewers understand that they do not manipulate the results in any way.
Said in jest while wearing white lab coat and stethoscope, Alcasid said:
“Ang gusto ko lang sabihin, hindi namin dinodoktor dito ang resulta kahit doctor ako (wearing white gown and stethoscope).”
